Logo
New year, new career — join us as a gaming news contributor or games reviewer!
  • First Impressions: KurtzPel
  • Battle Princess Madelyn Review
  • First Impressions: Hide or Die
  • Soul Calibur VI Review
  • SNK Heroines Review
  • Phantom Doctrine Review
  • All Reviews »

No Man’s Sky Review
Connor Corkhill @meetdamien

Sean Murray and Hello Games takes one giant leap into the world of space exploration, with potentially the most ambitious and hyped-up video game to date. The question is, does it live up to the hype?

No Man’s Sky. Every self-proclaimed gamer should be very familiar with this title. Famous for the colossal hype that has been built up since its 2013 reveal, and for the disgruntled reactions of thousands of gamers post release, the game has been getting a lot of negative attention recently. Is this because the game itself is bad? Or is it because it didn’t live up to the impossible standards that every gamer had set after letting their imaginations run wild? There is some truth to both of these points, yet the game might not be as terrible as people are making it out to be.

GAMEPLAY

20160813204308_1

The gameplay in No Man’s Sky revolves mainly around resource collecting and heading towards your choice of goal; the path of the Atlas or the journey to the galactic centre. No matter which you choose, the gameplay remains very similar sadly, revolving around a constant grind for materials to craft warp cells so that you can move on to the next star… then the next star… and another one… and well, this is No Man’s Sky in a nutshell. You can set yourself other goals of course such as scanning 100% of the organisms on a planet, but you would probably get bored of doing this after only a few planets.

Flying your starship in open space is enjoyable, except for when you encounter space pirates. The ship rotates slowly as if flying through treacle, making combat difficult and almost always resulting in your death. On a planet, flight feels restricted and bugged, like it’s using a sort of pseudo-autopilot that can’t make up its mind, sometimes erratically shooting you up into the atmosphere again for no apparent reason. Like all things in the game, flight becomes boring and feels like a chore after a while, bringing us to the game’s biggest weakness – longevity. The game struggles to offer anything new and interesting to keep you entertained after the first few hours, with the average users experience going something like this:

  • Hours 0-2: Your jaw drops. Everything is new and beautiful. You hastily explore every nook and cranny of your first few planets; your curiosity insatiable.
  • Hours 2-5: You’re more used to the freedom that the game offers now, and you start to focus on the upgrading your ship and crafting warp cells. You start skipping a few planets.
  • Hours 5-10: You only land on one planet per star now, you start to notice similarities in them. The voice of your personal assistant is beginning to irritate you.
  • Hours 10-15: A black hole broke your warp drive for the sixth time. Back to farming minerals… again. The odious voice of that vile assistant repeats, “Life support low” while your life support sits at 75%. Your anger grows.
  • Hours 15-20: Your warp drive broke again and you need 1000 more Iridium to fix it. You smash your head against your keyboard.

Constant, niggling issues take away from the core experience of the game, such as the aforementioned personal assistant and the extremely irritating lack of inventory space. Gamers that have been following the progress of No Man’s Sky for a while will also notice that features Sean Murray promised are missing, such as multiplayer, warring factions, faction reputation, derelict ships, landing on asteroids, large-scale space combat, planetary physics and the list goes on and on.

VISUALS

20160815231207_1

No Man’s Sky’s visual style is unique in the fact that you either love it, or you hate it. Certainly the chalky pale greens and pastel reds aren’t for everyone, but you can’t have a game of this size made in CryEngine can you? Jokes aside, the game is rather nice to look at — if you get a nice looking planet that is. My luck was rather awful and 9/10 of the planets I visited were desolate wastes but that doesn’t mean that they all are. Some are lush planets with fields of verdant vegetation, and some are ocean planets with little land. When you find one of the aforementioned planets, expect to fill your hard drive with screenshots as they are truly a wondrous sight to behold.

On the other hand, one major issue seems to exist within the game. Ore veins that have already been mined are rendered in as if they haven’t been mined from a distance, just to disappear again when you get closer, resulting in some unnecessary frustration and confusion. The way that the planet surfaces render in is also rather ugly at times, this is accentuated when activating beacon waypoints.

Audio

Quaint and dithery tones accompany the gameplay of No Man’s Sky, and are rather pleasant actually. Hello Games chose wisely to source their ‘Music for an Infinite Universe’ from British math rock band 65daysofstatic, as it complimented the games atmosphere well. The soundtrack also seamlessly changes depending on what is happening in the game. Ambient sound effects such as wind and rain enhance the realism and immersion while playing the game, making the shelters and outposts feel all the more cosey in harsh weather conditions.

20160815234302_1

Deserving of the hate?

No Man’s Sky is a candle in the wind; it’s a fun game at first, but the fun doesn’t last for long because you run out of things to do. It does show promise, but the game feels incomplete. It’s easy to understand why the fans are so annoyed, but Hello Games isn’t a triple-A studio. It’s just a typical case of the hype being so much that the game could never achieve what fans expected. Perhaps, with many updates, the game could become the game that everyone hoped it would.

No Man's Sky — the lowdown Game Windows 10
  • A massive achievement in procedural generation
  • Amazing sense of wonder in the first few hours
  • The galactic map is beautiful
  • Promised features are missing
  • Game gets repetitive and lacks depth
  • Triple-A price tag
  • Summary

    An awe-inspiring breakthrough in procedural generation technology that could become a great game after several updates, but for now, it's not worth buying unless at a heavily discounted price.

    4.5
    Awful
    Avoid this game. You'll have more fun burping into a blender.
    Mediocre
    Average at best. Consider if cheap or part of a bundle.
    Good
    Grab this if you're a fan of the genre. If not, rent or demo first.
    Great
    Recommended. You'll probably enjoy this game. Thank me later.
    Must-have
    Buy this immediately. Seriously. Go out and get this ASAP.
    GameCynic purchased a copy of this game to review. This does not impact our review or score. We reviewed the PC version.

    No Man's Sky

    Hello Games PC • PS4 Release: August 12, 2016 Play now

    Author: Connor Corkhill

    Hello! My name is Connor. I’m from the UK and gaming has been a massive part of my life since I was around 4 years old. I collect most things related to gaming, having a huge variety of games, classic consoles, figures and replicas (my Epic Weapons Frostmourne being perhaps my most prized of the lot). I love creative writing, be it writing reviews or my own short stories, and I also enjoy Viking battle re-enactment and blacksmithing. My favourite video games of all time include but are not limited to: Metroid Prime, Demon's Souls, Legacy of Kain: Defiance and DOTA 2.

    BNet: Sacrilege#1973 PSN: SacrilegeGG Steam: SacrilegeGG Twitter: @meetdamien

    Games currently in review

    • Bannermen
    • CrossCode
    • Slay the Spire
    • The Council

    We write richer, more in-depth reviews than most outlets, so our reviews take more time and we have to be very selective about which games to review. We believe the quality and integrity of our reviews makes up for the wait.

    Latest reviews

    5.3 Battle Princess MadelynDecember 6, 2018
    PC
    9.0 Soul Calibur VIOctober 17, 2018
    PlayStation 4
    6.4 SNK Heroines: Tag Team FrenzySeptember 6, 2018
    PlayStation 4
    7.7 Phantom DoctrineAugust 14, 2018
    PC
    9.2 Overcooked! 2August 7, 2018
    PC
    7.2 AIRHEART - Tales of Broken WingsJuly 24, 2018
    PC
    7.8 MoonlighterJuly 12, 2018
    PC
    8.1 Rainbow SkiesJune 26, 2018
    PlayStation 4
    8.8 OmensightMay 15, 2018
    PC
    8.3 Friday the 13th: Killer PuzzleApril 13, 2018
    PC
    7.2 The Witch and the Hundred Knight 2March 26, 2018
    PlayStation 4
    7.1 Super SeducerMarch 6, 2018
    PC
    6.8 Seven: The Days Long GoneJanuary 9, 2018
    PC
    6.1 Destiny 2: Curse of OsirisDecember 7, 2017
    PC
    7.5 Starpoint Gemini WarlordsDecember 1, 2017
    PC
    4.2 Friday the 13th: The GameNovember 16, 2017
    PlayStation 4
    8.1 Hand of Fate 2November 6, 2017
    PC
    8.2 A Hat In TimeNovember 6, 2017
    PC
    8.1 The Mummy DemasteredOctober 24, 2017
    PC
    6.2 NeofeudOctober 2, 2017
    PC
    See All Reviews »
    Our reviews are listed on

    Battle Princess Madelyn Review

    Co-designed by the developer’s young daughter, this loveletter to Ghouls ‘n Ghosts is unfortunately marred by incredibly frustrating design choices, poor mechanics and directionless level design.

    Read full article »

    Soul Calibur VI Review

    Soul Calibur VI returns to its roots, embracing the original ideologies in a semi-reboot which manages to bring the Calibur series back to its glory days.

    Read full article »

    SNK Heroines Review

    Buxom girls with cheeky costumes and sassy one-liners: SNK Heroines revels in offering a more lighthearted, comedic fighting game for SNK fans to jump into and mess around in.

    Read full article »

    Phantom Doctrine Review

    While some may initially dismiss it as “XCOM with spies”, Phantom Doctrine is far richer than that, standing strongly on its own merits with an evolving story of espionage and domination.

    Read full article »

    Overcooked 2 Review

    Overcooked! 2 drops you and up to three friends into an array of wild and wacky kitchens, desperately racing against the clock to make and serve dishes while a host of hazards — especially your own lack of teamwork — conspire against you.

    Read full article »

    Airheart Review

    A dieselpunk styled top-down shooter, Airheart drops you into the pilot seat of a small yet sturdy fishing plane, tackling pirates and collecting skyfish to ultimately reach and take down the great whale in the sky — a bounty of untold riches.

    Read full article »

    Moonlighter Review

    Part shop simulator, part dungeon crawler, Moonlighter puts you in the shoes of merchant Will, who bounces between managing his family store and diving into dungeons for adventure and marketable loot.

    Read full article »

    Rainbow Skies Review

    Rainbow Skies is a lighthearted tactical RPG that takes many of the best parts of modern peers and refines them into a fun adventure that’s easy to dive into.

    Read full article »

    Omensight Review

    The Godless-Priestess is dead. Murdered by an unknown hand, her death sets in motion the coming of Voden and with it, global annihilation. You play as the Harbinger, attempting to direct the machinations of key characters during the final day to prevent Voden’s arrival and ultimately saving the world.

    Read full article »

    Friday the 13th: Killer Puzzle Review

    Jason Voorhees returns to brutally massacre scores of hapless teens in fun new free to play puzzler.

    Read full article »

    The Witch and the Hundred Knight 2 Review

    Hack and slash/action RPG The Witch and the Hundred Knight 2 follows the story of distraught Amalie as she struggles to fight against a witch who has possessed the body of her younger sister, Milm.

    Read full article »

    Super Seducer Review

    Less game and more training tool, pick-up artist Richard La Ruina’s Super Seducer aims to help hapless guys up their dating game and get those girls every time. Let’s put it to the test.

    Read full article »

    Seven: The Days Long Gone Review

    This open-world stealth action RPG has some great ideas but, wrought by poor execution, turns out to be a frustrating experience.

    Read full article »

    Destiny 2: Curse of Osiris Review

    The first expansion for Destiny 2 just dropped, promising new locations to explore, increased player levels and exciting new adventures.

    Read full article »

    Starpoint Gemini Warlords Review

    Taking a typical space sandbox and bolting on an RPG-esque progression tree, Starpoint Gemini Warlords aims to offer a richer and more varied space exploration experience.

    Read full article »

    Friday The 13th: The Game Review

    Hoping to latch on to the success of asymmetric multiplayer survival hit Dead By Daylight, Friday the 13th: The Game pits fearful camp counsellors against the unstoppable Jason Voorhees. Great premise, marred by awful execution.

    Read full article »

    Hand of Fate 2 Review

    The dealer places the cards face down, each one offering new opportunities for fame and fortune, but also danger. Combining tabletop RPG and third-person combat, we journey through a multitude of quests where you help choose what encounters you’re willing to tackle.

    Read full article »

    A Hat In Time Review

    We look at Kickstarter darling A Hat In Time, an adorable 3D platform adventure following a young girl and her numerous magical hats as she explores an array of eclectic, unforgettable worlds.

    Read full article »

    The Mummy Demastered Review

    Based loosely on the summer blockbuster, The Mummy Demastered is a 16-bit inspired metroidvania which has you exploring forests, labs and catacombs in order to thwart the resurrection of an ancient Egyptian evil.

    Read full article »

    Neofeud Review

    This handpainted point and click adventure follows social worker Karl Carbon as he falls down a rabbit hole of segregational conspiracies in a dystopian world out to control the masses.

    Read full article »
    All content © 2016-2019 GameCynic unless otherwise indicated. All rights reserved.
    Meet the GameCynic team • Write for us and review games
    Email us at hellogamecynic.com