Logo
  • Friday the 13th: Killer Puzzle Review
  • First Look: Double Kick Heroes
  • The Witch and the Hundred Knight 2 Review
  • Super Seducer Review
  • Critical Hit: Dead By Daylight
  • Seven: The Days Long Gone Review
  • All Reviews »

Hand of Fate 2 Review

Evolving the unique gameplay into a more cohesive, enjoyable experience Damien King — November 6, 2017

Combining tabletop roleplay, deckbuilding, and Arkham-style combat, Hand of Fate 2 brings together a hearty mix of decision making and short fight scenes in a cohesive, exciting adventure.

If you’ve played the first Hand of Fate, you’ll know what to expect — the interesting subtleties of planning encounters in a deck and how to best approach various tasks remain, but the sequel helps bring everything together much more smoothly, with combat in particular feeling much more enjoyable: enemy attacks are better telegraphed, while animation and general flow of combat has had a serious polish.

Choose your own adventure

Hand of Fate 2 revolves around a series of quests, which are standard roleplay fare, whether it’s seeking out and killing a powerful enemy or tracking down a magical artifact or blessing. Quests are played out by way of cards laid face down on the table in front of you to journey across as you see fit, each card representing an encounter such as a hostile ambush, a chance at loot, or a new location of interest for later. A deck’s cards are chosen by you before you begin (with a few extra thrown in by the dealer), which lets you pick and choose which encounters you want to run into along your journey.

Certain cards have tokens attached, which can be claimed if you successfully beat such encounter; once a quest is completed, all tokens won grant new cards for later selection, including new side missions, items and equipment, or foes to tackle.

Planning each quest thus becomes one of the more tactical parts of Hand of Fate 2 as you plan which encounters you’d like on the table, given that there is a hard limit on how many you can include; do you take that card that always grants useful supplies to help you keep going through a tough quest, or risk running a new card to discover what it offers and potentially unlock additional new cards?

Much of the gameplay remains at the tabletop, where you’ll be guiding yourself across the board from card to card, making decisions as you discover new people and situations, though occasionally you’ll be pulled into a fight whether by choice or fate. Here the game changes, dropping you into realtime third-person combat where you’ll need to take down your opponents or die trying.

Combat is fairly straightforward, with the options of standard slicing strikes as well as heavier attacks to stagger opponents who may be adept at blocking or evading your regular attacks. Enemies on the attack will telegraph their next move, signalling whether or not it’s blockable; blockable attacks can be countered, leading to a slightly Arkham-esque style of fighting as you pummel crowds of enemies, deftly counterattacking and dodging as needed. Once you’re used to the controls, combat flow feels good, and becomes a lot of fun.

Combat, while not groundbreaking in any way, remains short enough to avoid monotony, and challenging enough to force you to pay attention, especially with the tricks that bosses can bring to the fight. You won’t be alone in combat, however — across your adventures you’ll run into a roster of unlikely characters who’ll become companions, and you’ll be able to choose one to bring along for aid in any quest.

Beyond a small help in combat, companions also serve a bigger purpose of having their own questlines; bringing a particular companion and their current quest cards into a quest reduces the other options you could bring along, but you’ll learn more about their backgrounds and motives, as well as scoring some rather interesting new encounter and loot cards.

Back at the tabletop, the ominous dealer introduces new tricks in Hand of Fate 2 to keep you on your toes. Attempts at heroics, such as saving villagers from a burning house or swiftly dodging a sprung trap can trigger different types of luck or skill checks. A common one you’ll face is a simple dice roll, where you’ll need to roll three dice and hope to match a particular target; another is the wheel, where spinning cards will require you to stop them on a safe pick — or face punishment.

Each quest also tends to favor a particular gimmick or quirk to mix things up; an early quest has you traversing a dangerous, snowy mountain, so the dealer will add a number of freezing blizzard cards to the deck, each rapidly draining your health as you become trapped in them and forcing you to consume more of your ever-dwindling food supplies.

These different challenges help bring a little variety to otherwise straightforward gameplay, forcing you to rush through a quest, seek and collect particular objects, or beat the odds to successfully perform enough heroic deeds for fame. Paired with the steady depletion of food as you move from card to card, and the inevitable loss of health from tough combat and failed challenges, and the difficulty can catch you unawares if you’re not paying attention to all the details in front of you.

The game never feels overly punishing, however; while difficulty naturally rises over time with the inclusion of tougher opponents and trickier challenges, so too does the availability of powerful gear to trade or loot. Progression throughout Hand of Fate 2 feels fair, and moves along at a decent pace, perhaps slightly faster than the original.

Hand of Fate 2 — the lowdown Game Windows 10
  • Improved combat mechanics
  • Plenty of cards to collect and engage with
  • Well-tuned difficulty curve keeps things interesting
  • Can be a little repetitive towards the end
  • Perhaps a little short
  • Not a huge variety of enemies
  • Summary

    Part tabletop adventure, part third-person combat, Hand of Fate 2 is an unusual amalgamation which successfully manages to let you tailor and experience a multitude of quests. Improving upon the original with more focused direction, customisation and improved combat flow, RPG and "choose your own adventure" fans should certainly take a look.

    8.1
    Awful
    Avoid this game. You'll have more fun burping into a blender.
    Mediocre
    Average at best. Consider if cheap or part of a bundle.
    Good
    Grab this if you're a fan of the genre. If not, rent or demo first.
    Great
    Recommended. You'll probably enjoy this game. Thank me later.
    Must-have
    Buy this immediately. Seriously. Go out and get this ASAP.
    GameCynic received a promotional copy of this game to review. This does not impact our review or score. We reviewed the PC version.

    Hand of Fate 2

    Defiant Development PC • PS4 • XB1 Release: November 7, 2017 Play now

    Author: Damien King

    A quintessential Englishman now living in the United States, Damien is a born-and-raised gamer since the Atari 2600 days of antiquity. Husband, puppy parent, and workaholic entrepreneur, he spends most of his time in some form of creative capacity — be it web design, consulting, or writing as a games critic.

    BNet: Sacrilege#1973 PSN: SacrilegeGG Steam: SacrilegeGG Twitter: @meetdamien

    Latest reviews

    8.3 Friday the 13th: Killer Puzzle
    7.2 The Witch and the Hundred Knight 2
    7.1 Super Seducer
    6.8 Seven: The Days Long Gone
    6.1 Destiny 2: Curse of Osiris
    7.5 Starpoint Gemini Warlords
    4.2 Friday the 13th: The Game
    8.1 Hand of Fate 2
    8.2 A Hat In Time
    8.1 The Mummy Demastered
    6.2 Neofeud
    8.3 Cuphead
    9.4 Destiny 2
    9.3 SteamWorld Dig 2
    6.8 Pankapu
    8.7 Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony
    7.1 Zero Escape: Zero Time Dilemma
    8.3 The Escapists 2
    7.9 Sudden Strike 4
    8.0 Aven Colony

    Reviews in progress

    First Look  
    City of Brass
    Review  
    Warhammer: Vermintide II
    Review  
    Fidel
    First Look  
    Hyper Universe
    Review  
    Hello Neighbor
    First Look  
    Insidia
    Review  
    Battle Chasers: Nightwar

    Coming up soon

    Review  
    Book Of Demons
    Review  
    Into the Breach
    First Look  
    Ylands
    Review  
    Holy Potatoes! What The Hell?!
    Review  
    Party Hard Tycoon
    Review  
    Hob
    Review  
    Golem Gates
    Our reviews are listed on

    Friday the 13th: Killer Puzzle Review

    Jason Voorhees returns to brutally massacre scores of hapless teens in fun new free to play puzzler.

    Read full article »

    The Witch and the Hundred Knight 2 Review

    Hack and slash/action RPG The Witch and the Hundred Knight 2 follows the story of distraught Amalie as she struggles to fight against a witch who has possessed the body of her younger sister, Milm.

    Read full article »

    Super Seducer Review

    Less game and more training tool, pick-up artist Richard La Ruina’s Super Seducer aims to help hapless guys up their dating game and get those girls every time. Let’s put it to the test.

    Read full article »

    Seven: The Days Long Gone Review

    This open-world stealth action RPG has some great ideas but, wrought by poor execution, turns out to be a frustrating experience.

    Read full article »

    Destiny 2: Curse of Osiris Review

    The first expansion for Destiny 2 just dropped, promising new locations to explore, increased player levels and exciting new adventures.

    Read full article »

    Starpoint Gemini Warlords Review

    Taking a typical space sandbox and bolting on an RPG-esque progression tree, Starpoint Gemini Warlords aims to offer a richer and more varied space exploration experience.

    Read full article »

    Friday The 13th: The Game Review

    Hoping to latch on to the success of asymmetric multiplayer survival hit Dead By Daylight, Friday the 13th: The Game pits fearful camp counsellors against the unstoppable Jason Voorhees. Great premise, marred by awful execution.

    Read full article »

    A Hat In Time Review

    We look at Kickstarter darling A Hat In Time, an adorable 3D platform adventure following a young girl and her numerous magical hats as she explores an array of eclectic, unforgettable worlds.

    Read full article »

    The Mummy Demastered Review

    Based loosely on the summer blockbuster, The Mummy Demastered is a 16-bit inspired metroidvania which has you exploring forests, labs and catacombs in order to thwart the resurrection of an ancient Egyptian evil.

    Read full article »

    Neofeud Review

    This handpainted point and click adventure follows social worker Karl Carbon as he falls down a rabbit hole of segregational conspiracies in a dystopian world out to control the masses.

    Read full article »

    Cuphead Review

    With a gorgeous vintage cartoon style and outlandish boss battles, how does Cuphead’s classic gameplay style (read: very hard) fare for today’s gaming audience? We dive in to give a full verdict.

    Read full article »

    Destiny 2 Review

    We’ve lost and regained our Light. We’ve conquered new foes while reminding old enemies who to truly be afraid of. We’ve completed every story segment, banded together for every co-operative strike, and even taken down the dark foes of the Leviathan, Destiny 2’s debut raid. After putting a solid 50+ hours into Destiny 2, only one question matters: Is it fun?

    Read full article »

    SteamWorld Dig 2 Review

    Set a short time after the cult classic first game, SteamWorld Dig 2 is the compelling tale of steambot Dorothy as she seeks her friend and previous protagonist Rusty, who has mysteriously gone missing since the previous title.

    Read full article »

    Pankapu Review

    Split across multiple chapters, Pankapu is a deceptively tricky 2D platformer where you play as a dream guardian who slowly gains the ability to switch classes and powers on the fly.

    Read full article »

    Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony review

    Sixteen amnesiac strangers awaken to find themselves locked inside a mysterious school and forced to play a killing game: Murdering another student without being caught is the only way to escape.

    Read full article »

    Zero Time Dilemma Review

    Puzzles, paradoxes, and murder by numbers — this is the Decision Game.

    Read full article »

    The Escapists 2 Review

    I want to break free.

    Read full article »

    Sudden Strike 4 Review

    Punishing, tactical, methodical — welcome to war.

    Read full article »

    Aven Colony Review

    Sim City in space? We take a look at the anticipated colony sim and see if it meets expectations.

    Read full article »

    Master X Master

    We take a look at NCSOFT’s character switching, trigger twitching arenafest.

    Read full article »
    All content © 2016-2018 GameCynic unless otherwise indicated. All rights reserved.
    Meet the GameCynic team • Write for us and review games
    Email us at hellogamecynic.com